Skip to content
// guide · 5 min read

DMARC p=none vs quarantine vs reject: which should you use?

What each DMARC policy does, which one to use, and when it is safe to move from p=none to quarantine and then reject without blocking your own email.

Published

// short answer

p=none only watches and sends reports, p=quarantine asks mail providers to treat failing mail as suspicious (usually spam), and p=reject asks them to refuse it. Start at none, move to quarantine once your reports show every real sender passing, then move to reject.

If you have looked at your DMARC record, you have probably seen one of three words after p=: none, quarantine or reject. They decide what happens to email that claims to be from your business but isn't. Choosing the wrong one, or moving between them too quickly, is the most common way small businesses either leave the door open or block their own invoices.

This guide explains what each policy does, which one you should be on today, and how to move up safely.

The three policies at a glance

The three DMARC policies compared
PolicyWhat providers are asked to do with failing mailStops spoofing?Risk to your own mail
p=noneDeliver it as normal, but send you reportsNoNone
p=quarantineTreat it as suspicious, usually by putting it in spamPartlyLow, once your senders are set up
p=rejectRefuse it outrightYesLow, once your senders are set up

"Failing mail" means a message that uses your domain in the visible "From" address but passes neither SPF nor DKIM in a way that lines up with your domain. Mail providers treat the policy as a strong request rather than a strict rule, but the big ones generally follow it.

p=none: watch only

_dmarc.yourbusiness.co.za  TXT  "v=DMARC1; p=none; rua=mailto:dmarc@yourbusiness.co.za"

p=none changes nothing about delivery. Its job is to switch on reporting. Mail providers that support DMARC send daily summary reports to the address in rua=, listing every server that sent mail using your domain and whether it passed.

That is genuinely useful: it is the only reliable way to find every service sending as you. Think of your mailbox provider, your website's contact form, your invoicing tool and your newsletter platform. But it does not stop a single fake message. A record left on p=none for years is like a burglar alarm on silent.

Use it when: you are setting up DMARC for the first time, or you have added a new sending service and want to confirm it passes.

p=quarantine: send fakes to spam

_dmarc.yourbusiness.co.za  TXT  "v=DMARC1; p=quarantine; rua=mailto:dmarc@yourbusiness.co.za"

With quarantine, mail providers are asked to treat failing messages as suspicious. In practice that usually means the spam or junk folder. Your customers are much less likely to see a fake invoice, and if one of your own services is misconfigured, its mail lands in spam rather than disappearing, which is easier to notice and recover from.

You can also apply quarantine gradually with pct=. For example, p=quarantine; pct=25 asks providers to quarantine a quarter of failing mail and apply the next lower policy to the rest. It is a gentle way to test. Once you are confident, remove pct= (it defaults to 100).

Use it when: your reports have shown your genuine senders passing for a few weeks.

p=reject: block fakes

_dmarc.yourbusiness.co.za  TXT  "v=DMARC1; p=reject; rua=mailto:dmarc@yourbusiness.co.za"

reject asks mail providers to refuse failing messages before they reach anyone's inbox. This is the setting that actually stops email spoofing of your domain. It is where you want to end up.

The only risk is the same as with quarantine, but sharper: if one of your real services is not set up properly, its messages are refused instead of going to spam. That is why you get here in steps.

Use it when: quarantine has run for a while and your reports show only genuine senders passing and only fakes failing.

Which policy should you be on today?

  • No DMARC record yet: publish p=none with a report address this week.
  • On p=none with reports coming in: check them. If every service you recognise passes, move to quarantine.
  • On p=none with no rua=: add a report address first. Without reports you have no evidence that tightening is safe.
  • On quarantine for a few weeks with nothing genuine in spam: move to reject.
  • On reject: keep the reports flowing and recheck whenever you add a new tool that sends email.

// free, passive, 30 seconds

See which policy your domain uses

Run the free check

A safe path from none to reject

  1. Make sure SPF and DKIM are set up for your main mailbox provider. Most providers have a setup page that gives you the exact records. Our SPF checker will show whether your SPF record is healthy.
  2. Publish p=none with a rua= address. Raw reports are machine-readable files, so many people send them to a report-reading service.
  3. Read the reports for two to four weeks. List every service sending as you. For each genuine one that fails, add it to SPF or turn on DKIM signing for it.
  4. Move to p=quarantine, optionally with pct= to start small.
  5. Watch for complaints of missing mail and check spam folders for anything genuine.
  6. Move to p=reject.

Common mistakes when changing policy

  • Jumping straight to reject. This is how contact-form emails and invoices from accounting tools start disappearing.
  • Forgetting subdomains. By default the policy also applies to subdomains. If a subdomain sends mail through a different service, either set it up properly or use sp= to give subdomains their own policy.
  • Leaving pct= behind. A forgotten pct=10 means 90% of fakes still get the weaker treatment.
  • Breaking SPF while you work. Adding a new service as a second SPF record, or going over the ten-lookup limit, makes SPF fail for all your mail. Our guide to SPF "too many DNS lookups" covers that.

How to check where you are

The free DMARC checker reads your public _dmarc record and shows your policy, subdomain policy, percentage and report address, in plain English. It only reads public DNS, so it is safe to run at any time. If you are new to the topic, start with what is DMARC, and does my small business need it?.

Want someone to do it for you?

Moving to reject is usually a short job once you know who sends mail as you. Finding that out is the fiddly part. Odesstra can read your reports, set up the missing senders and step your policy up safely. See website security fixes for how quoting works.

Questions

Is p=none better than no DMARC record?

Yes, a little. It starts the reports that tell you who sends mail as you. But it does not stop fake email, so treat it as a starting point, not the finish line.

How long should I stay on p=none?

Long enough to see every service that sends as you pass SPF or DKIM in the reports. For many small businesses that is two to four weeks, longer if some mail, such as monthly invoices, hasn't shown up in the reports yet.

What does pct= do?

It applies a quarantine or reject policy to only a percentage of failing mail, for example pct=25. It is a way to tighten gradually. Remove it, or set it to 100, once you are confident.

Does p=reject affect my subdomains?

By default the policy covers subdomains too, unless you publish a separate sp= value. Our DMARC checker shows both.

Talk to a human