What does my website security grade mean? A to F explained
What an A to F website security grade or score really measures, why different tools disagree, what it cannot tell you, and which fixes to do first.
Published
// short answer
A website security grade summarises how well the settings visible from outside are configured, such as your certificate, security headers and email records. It does not show whether your site has been hacked or its software is up to date, so an A is a good start, not proof of safety.
You ran a security check on your website and got a letter: an A, a C, maybe an F. Another tool gave a different letter for the same site. What does the grade actually measure, and what should you do about it?
This guide explains how website security grades work in general, how ours is worked out, and how to turn a grade into a short, sensible to-do list.
What a grade measures
Most free website security graders, including ours, are passive. They look at what any visitor's browser or mail server can already see:
- your SSL certificate and TLS connection
- whether
http://redirects tohttps:// - the security headers your server sends, such as HSTS and Content Security Policy
- your email protection records, SPF and DMARC
- whether your site advertises its software versions (version disclosure)
- whether the page loads anything over plain
http://(mixed content)
Each problem found is given a weight, and the weights are combined into a letter. A grade is therefore a summary of configuration: how well the parts of your site that face the outside world are set up.
What a grade does not measure
This is the part that matters most, and it is often left out.
A passive grade cannot see:
- whether your site has already been hacked or contains malware
- whether WordPress, plugins or themes behind your login are out of date
- weak or reused passwords, or admin accounts without two-factor authentication
- flaws in your site's own code, such as SQL injection
- whether your backups work
So an A means "the front door is well built". It does not mean nobody can get in some other way. No honest tool can promise your site is secure from the outside alone.
How our grade works
Our free website security check gives every finding a severity and works out the grade the same way every time, with no randomness and no "bonus points". Each run starts at 100. A high-severity finding takes off 25 points, a medium one 10 and a low one 4. The total maps to a letter: 90 or more is an A, 80 a B, 65 a C, 50 a D, and anything lower an F. If the certificate or headers part of the check could not run, we show no grade rather than guess.
| Grade | What it usually means | How urgent |
|---|---|---|
| A | The visible basics look well set up | Keep it that way; recheck after changes |
| B | One or two small gaps, often a header | Fix when convenient |
| C | A handful of fixable settings | Plan the fixes this month |
| D | Several gaps, often including a serious one | Fix soon |
| F | Several serious problems, such as a broken padlock plus missing protections | Fix now |
Serious problems count for much more than small ones. Any high-severity finding, such as an expired certificate, means the grade cannot be higher than a C, however good everything else is. A missing Permissions-Policy header, by contrast, barely moves it. That matches what visitors and mail providers actually notice.
Why different tools disagree
It is normal for two tools to give the same site different grades:
- They check different things. A headers-only grader ignores your certificate and email records. A certificate-only tool ignores your headers. A combined check like ours looks at all of them.
- They weigh things differently. Some graders fail any site without a Content Security Policy. Others treat it as one item among many.
- They see different pages. A tool that tests a different page or follows redirects differently may see different headers.
Read the findings, not just the letter. The findings tell you what to change; the letter only tells you roughly how much.
// free, passive, 30 seconds
Get your grade and top three fixes
Turning the grade into a to-do list
Whatever tool you used, this order works for most small business sites:
- Anything visitors can see. An expired or mismatched certificate, or no redirect to HTTPS. These cost you visitors today.
- Email protection. No DMARC, or DMARC on
p=none, means scammers can send email that looks like yours. See DMARC p=none vs quarantine vs reject. - The protective headers. HSTS, clickjacking protection and nosniff are usually quick. A Content Security Policy takes more care. Our guide to the six security headers every website should send gives safe starting values.
- Tidy-up. Hide software version numbers, add a CAA record, remove leftover
http://links.
Then look at what the grade can't see: updates, passwords, two-factor authentication and backups. The website security checklist for small businesses covers those.
Should you chase an A+?
Not for its own sake. A perfect score on a headers grader can mean a very strict Content Security Policy that breaks your contact form or analytics. Aim for the fixes that protect your visitors and your email, test that nothing breaks, and treat the grade as a progress marker rather than the goal.
Want a human to read it with you?
A grade with a list of findings is a good start, but deciding what is worth fixing, and in what order, is where most people want a second opinion. Odesstra is run by a web developer who can explain your results, quote a fixed price for the fixes and recheck afterwards. See website security fixes, or talk to a human.